9 Best Custom Sofas: Top Picks for Style, Comfort & Durability

The right sofa can transform a bland space into a stylish, warm, inviting sanctuary for your household and guests. 

Moreso, when you can personalize the sofa based on your unique taste and complement your interior style.

However, finding the right sofa can be daunting and time-consuming. That’s why we’ve done all the hard yards for you and curated a list of the 10 best custom sofas. 

We’ve ensured this list is diverse, from statement pieces to modular sofas, so there’s something for everyone. 

Below, we examine these custom sofas, highlighting why we love them, what sets them apart, and customer sentiments to help you make an informed decision.

1. DreamSofa Gosford Naples Pool Sofa: Best overall custom sofa 

Gosford Naples Pool Sofa is one of DreamSofa’s most stylish and elegant offerings. It’s so chic, clean, and screams high-end. We particularly love that it can equally work in more formal spaces.

If you’re looking for a unique, customizable, meticulously constructed, and high-end statement piece for your space, the Gosford Naples Pool Sofa is The One. 

DreamSofa specializes in helping you design the furniture of your dreams exactly as you imagined it. We give you complete control over dimensions, fabrics, comfort level, and finishes so you’re not forever stuck with an option you settled for.  You choose the exact size of the sofa, starting from 35 inches up to 109 inches. There are also over 1,500 fabric choices and multiple finishes, including more minor details like nailhead color to help you design it your way. 

Like all DreamSofa furniture, the Gosford Naples Pool Sofa is made from certified sustainable kiln-dried pine and solidwoods, which prevent warping and cracking. 

The stress joints of the sofa are also reinforced for added stability and sturdiness. 

In addition to this, the sofas are fabricated with hand-tied eight-way and sinuous spring systems, ensuring the sofa sofas maintain their structure and support for years. 

Ordering custom furniture often means long wait times and far-away delivery dates, but not with DreamSofa. DreamSofa offers a turnaround of 4 weeks, a fraction of the time compared to other custom furniture brands. Dreamsofa delivers true value by cutting out the middleman and avoiding unnecessary markups, so you enjoy premium quality without breaking the bank.

Many brands promise excellent customer service, but the experience is disappointing, not DreamSofa. Buying a custom sofa may be overwhelming, with thousands of possible combinations making you dizzy. DreamSofa’s support staff can help with fabric choices, size recommendations, and any questions you might have. They can also collaborate with you to design the sofa based on your specifications.

Key features

• Removable cushions
• Diamond tufting and nailheads
• Fully customizable
• Metallic legs
• Padded cushions
• High-back design
• Available in premium leather and stylish fabrics

What customers are saying

DreamSofa has an impressive 4.9-star rating from over 1,000 reviews across platforms like Yelp and Google Reviews. One of the major highlights from these reviews is how customers praise the seamless customization process and expert design guidance every customer can access. New and returning customers also rave about how DreamSofa exceeds their expectations in terms of sheer quality and costs.

2. Modular Bondi Latte 2-Seater Sofa by Inside Weather: Best affordable custom sofa

The Modular Bondi Latte 2-Seater Sofa by Inside Weather adapts effortlessly as your lifestyle does. 

Its modern, modular design allows you to reconfigure, expand, or rearrange each piece to suit your space as your needs or tastes evolve.

Beyond the calming tones of the Latte fabric, you can personalize nearly every element of the Bondi, from fabric and leg finish to cushion comfort.

The basket weave upholstery and frame make this perfect for a beach house. 

Key features

• Oversized cushions
• Washable covers
• Life-proof seating
• Machine Washable 
• PFAS-Free & Oeko-Tex® Certified
• Three wood finishes

What customers are saying 

Reviews reveal that customers are pleased with their purchase. Customers consistently highlight the sofa’s cozy and comfortable cushions. They also praise how easy it is to customize using the website.

3. The Dune Sofa By Maiden Home: Best minimalist custom sofa

The Dune Sofa ticks all the right boxes if you want a low-profile, minimalist, unassuming sofa style. 

This sofa features plush cushioning, an inviting seat depth, and a made-to-fit slipcover that screams casual elegance.

As a deep, sink-in-by-design sofa, the Dune is just the right sofa for Netflix and chill nights, lounging, and even catching well-deserved afternoon naps. 

The minimalist nature of this sofa means you have a blank canvas you can layer with different textures, mainly throw pillows, for that extra oomph in your living room. 

One of its standout features is the stain-resistant performance fabrics, which makes it a dream for busy households with pets and infants/toddlers.

You also have diverse upholstery options like Heritage Belgian Linen Alder, Performance Textured Linen, and Heritage Belgian Linen. Other ways to add your own flair to the Dune Sofa include size and cushion filling with either feathers or an alternative.  

Key features

• Relaxed slipcover
• Available in classic back or scatter-back styles
• 60–120 inches
• Fabric upholstery only
• White glove delivery

What customers are saying

The Dune Sofa is often lauded for its quality craftsmanship and comfort. A reviewer who posted an update two years after delivery touted how the seat cushions have retained their shape and sturdiness. They also note how the fabric also passed the test of time. 

4. American Leather’s Astoria Sofa: Best custom leather sofa

The attention to detail on the Astoria Sofa lands it on our list. The Astoria sofa easily comes to mind when we think of understated elegance coupled with comfort.

This sofa is shaped like open arms, ready to embrace your warmth. It is inviting and the epitome of expert craftsmanship. 

With its buttonless tufted bench seat, compact track arms, and exposed wooden block feet, this sofa has everything to fit into many types of interior design. The Astoria sofa will fit like a glove, whether it’s Bohemian, Scandinavian, or contemporary style. 

The double-needle stitching on the seams when you opt for leather is unmissable. It adds an extra level of sophistication to the sofa in the way it subtly contrasts the smooth leather. 

We also love that the wooden legs are available in four different colors (dune, ebony, mink, and oiled ash), allowing you to add an element of contrast to the furniture itself and perhaps the room. 

Speaking of customizations, you cannot change the sofa size, but it’s available in 100s of leather and fabric shades and colors. 

If you like high-end European furnishings, the Astoria is one of the pieces by American Leather constructed using the European upholstery method of excellent clean lines and seams. 

Key features

• European upholstery method
• Buttonless tufting
• Available in leather and fabric upholstery
• Double-needle stitching on the seams
• Wooden legs

What customers are saying

One minor downside is that you can not order directly from American Leather. Although you can customize the sofa to your taste on the American Leather website, you must purchase from other retailers. 

Many reviewers share positive sentiments about American Leather’s use of top-quality materials and exceptional craftsmanship. 

5. Maxwell Fabric Sofa by Apartment Therapy and Interior Define: Best affordable custom sofa

Designed by Apartment Therapy’s founder, Maxwell Ryan, in collaboration with Interior Define, this sofa takes a fresh spin on traditional sofa shapes.

Its understated profile and luxuriously deep seat invite you to sit back, relax, and chill. Its thick, contoured arms project a perfect structure, just like a person with perfect posture and gait. 

You’ll also love the piping details on this one, adding that extra touch of mid-century sophistication. It also comes included at no additional cost. 

This sofa features a layered cushion design that you can upgrade to extra-soft cushions per your desired comfort level and firmness. 

The Maxwell Fabric Sofa by Apartment Therapy offers a wide range of customization options. In particular, you can alter the legs in about 35+ ways, not just the color but also the type and shape. 

You may also specify if you want the sofa in split cushions or as a bench cushion; the latter requires an additional outlay. Surprisingly, the Maxwell Sofa only comes in three dimensions: 82 inches, 86 inches, and 90 inches.

Key features

• Piping details
• Thinner frame rail
• Deep seat sofa
• Lumbar pillows
• Contoured arms

What customers are saying

Customers enjoy the support and help they receive. Elise J from Brooklyn wrote that they received incredible attention throughout the entire design and delivery process. 

While others focused their review on the quality of materials and craftsmanship, noting their purchase was value for money.

6. Range 3-Piece Sofa by Burrow: Best modular custom sofa

Raise your lounging game with Burrow’s 3-piece Sofa off the Range Collection. This is one of those conventional fabric sofas minus the boringness they’re known for. 

The Range sofa is the ideal gathering point for spending time with family and friends or binge-watching a marathon series and taking daytime naps. It features three spacious seats, soft, overstuffed cushions, and deep, expansive seats.

One of the truly outstanding features of the Range Collection is its universal modular system. So, what does that mean for you? 

It means you can pull the whole setup apart and arrange it in many ways. One minute, it’s part of a family seating area, and in another breath, you’ve rearranged it as your personal reading nook. 

In addition, it provides an easy way to make future upgrades. For example, you can move the configuration around to accommodate an attachable ottoman or coffee table. 

Key features

• Sink-in sofa
• Universal modular system
• Overstuffed cushions
• Bent plywood construction
• Stain-resistant fabrics

What customers are saying

Overall, the Range Collection has received many positive reviews. An overwhelming number of reviews mentioned how easy it was to set up the Range Sofa, and many reviewers also mentioned the sofa’s flexibility. 

7. Bryant Modular Sofa (3-piece) by Joybird: Best multipurpose custom sofa

The Bryant Modular Sofa offers endless possibilities, thanks to its flexibility as a modular furniture. 

This expertly crafted sofa is built for comfort and lazy lounging. It features an elegant structure, bouncy cushioning, sloped arms, and tender pillowed backing.

It’s hard to look beyond the “Build Your Own Bryant” feature that allows you to create the sofa of your choice. 

This is beyond changing colors or cushioning and about combining different Bryant pieces (armless chairs, corner chairs, and more) however you want. 

Also, there is a wide range of sustainable, pet-friendly, and stain-resistant performance fabrics, with fabric choices such as velvet, chenille, and microfiber. 

Key features

• Sloped arms
• Velvet fabrics
• Pet-friendly fabrics
• Concealed peg legs
• Minimal wood frame
• Nonreversible cushion

What customers are saying

The Bryant 3-Piece Sofa has received a pretty good average rating. Many customers attest to the sofa’s comfort and ample seating. 

8. The Lovesac Sactional Sofa: Best future-proof custom sofa

Imagine being able to customize your sofa to fit your unique space, mood, and need, with the freedom to add, remove, or rearrange pieces as you see fit. 

The Lovesac Sactional Sofa makes this a reality with its modular design and wide range of sizes, fabrics, patterns, and colors.

Aside from color, fabric, and cushion options, there are other significant stylistic choices you can make. 

For example, you can choose from three arm styles: standard, angled, or roll/rounded. You may also opt for either a straight or angled-back style. 

Such details can come in handy when designing for specific niche needs. 

The biggest draw of the Lovesac sofa is the add-ons. You can add a reclining seat or storage seat for more functionality, such as keeping your room neat.

Key features

• Modular design
• Machine-washable covers
• Add-ons such as storage space and recliners
• 200 cover design options

What customers are saying

A recurring theme from customer reviews is the high praise for the quality and comfort of the sofa. 

Customers also appreciated the quality of customer service they received, with a reviewer praising how knowledgeable, efficient, and friendly they were. 

On the flip side, many customers were surprised by the time-consuming nature of the assembly process. 

9. Catalina Sofa by Clad Home: Best custom fabric sofa

The Catalina Sofa by Clad Home is a unique representation of modern sofa trends. Its low-profile design, sloping arms, and plush cushioning create a welcoming ambiance in any living space.

This fully customizable sofa is designed for both durability and long-lasting comfort.

You can alter the sofa’s width and depth, fabric, cushion layout, leg style, leg finish, and cushion fill and add optional throws and pillows. 

The customization interface is also intuitive and easy to use. Clad Home also offers a Custom Concierge Program to consult with interior designers to further help potential customers build pieces they truly love. 

Key features

• Different leg styles
• Stuffed cushions
• Fully customizable
• Fabric upholstery only

What customers are saying

The overall customer sentiment is positive, with many reviews noting the quality of Clad Home products. Some customers also noted how the sofas were very comfortable, even for sleeping on.

Takeaway: DreamSofa stands out as the ultimate choice in custom sofas

Choosing the right custom sofa comes down to finding the right balance of style, comfort, durability, and cost, and each of the ten options in our guide brings something unique to the sofa table.

While individual preferences or needs may vary, the DreamSofa is the top pick based on value, customization options, and customer satisfaction.

If you’re looking for a high-quality, customizable sofa that offers unparalleled value, consider the DreamSofa Gosford Naples Pool Sofa. With its exceptional comfort, durability, and style, it’s an investment that will elevate your space for years to come. Customize yours today!

FAQs

Here are the answers to some frequently asked questions about sofas: 

How can you determine if a sofa is of high quality?

The best indicator of a sofa’s quality is what previous buyers say about it; after all, the proof is in the pudding. As such, seek out reviews from confirmed buyers.  

What is a reasonable cost for a high-quality sofa?

All sofas are not created equal and that’s just the reality. So, it’s hard to answer a very subjective question. Some sofas will cost more than others based on the size, materials, fabrics, colors, and structure. Ultimately, the right price for a high-quality sofa is one that fits your budget, meets your needs and provides long-term value. 

Are luxury sofas a worthwhile investment?

Luxury sofas are worthwhile investments. True luxury sofas use the highest-quality materials, are constructed with superior craftsmanship, quality fabrics, incredible designs, and high-resilience cushioning, and last for years to come. Even if the initial costs may be higher, the long-term durability makes them a worthwhile investment over sofas that require regular changes. 

Does white sofa fabric remain clean over time?

White sofa fabric can be a challenging choice when it comes to maintaining cleanliness over time. The major determinant of whether it remains clean over time is the fabric type used to construct the sofa. Stain-resistant and performance fabrics are easier to clean and do not retain stains. Additionally, other factors like usage, lifestyle, and regular maintenance also affect whether white sofa fabric remains clean over time. 

What is the difference between a sofa and a loveseat?

They are both from the same furniture family with the major difference being their sizes. A sofa is larger and may seat three or more people. In contrast, a loveseat is a more compact piece meant for two people. Loveseats work best for smaller spaces. With DreamSofa, you can turn any sofa of your choice into a loveseat by simply altering the dimensions.